FROM WILLIAM'S LEGACY CATALOGUES
26 August 2008 | Canon EOS-1Ds Mark III
The Loss of ‘Truth’: When a Film Truck Destroyed Two Centuries of History
I had assumed I had photographed the statue only once before the tragic incident that so many have since forgotten. However, after unearthing an old backup hard drive—and sourcing the right adapter to bridge the obsolete ports—I struck a goldmine of archive photographs from August 2008. Among them were clear, contextual studies of Truth standing proudly within the grounds of King’s Inns.
Long before the park was redefined by the relocation of the three 1872 Industrial Graces, an eighteenth-century neoclassical monument stood atop a stone plinth just yards from the Henrietta Street entrance. Known affectionately to generations of local residents as "Henrietta", the figure was an original late-Georgian allegory of Truth.
Subject: Allegory of Truth
Attribution: Circle of James Gandon and Edward Smyth
Origin: c. 1780s–1790s; Portland stone; salvaged from the Four Courts roofline
Status: Toppled and fractured in April 2012; fragments retained in conservation storage
Truth was conceived during Dublin’s golden age of Enlightenment architecture. Perched along the roofline balustrade of James Gandon’s Four Courts on Inns Quay, she watched over the city’s legal quarter until the catastrophic opening salvos of the Irish Civil War in June 1922. Although intense artillery shelling and subsequent fires gutted the Four Courts complex and incinerated centuries of Irish public records, this solitary Portland stone figure miraculously survived the collapse without catastrophic destruction.
During the extensive rebuilding campaign of the 1920s, the figure was transferred north to the dignified surroundings of the Honourable Society of King’s Inns, where she remained in quiet contemplation for almost nine decades.
That two-century lifespan came to an abrupt, avoidable end in April 2012. Henrietta Street and the King’s Inns campus were serving as historic sets for the Victorian television drama Ripper Street. Whilst manoeuvring near the entrance gates, a heavy logistics production lorry struck the base of the plinth. The impact threw the historic monument onto the paved ground below, snapping the neck and shattering the torso.
Following widespread dismay among conservationists, historians, and local heritage organisations, the fractured remains were retrieved and transferred into secure storage by the King’s Inns for preservation and assessment. While Truth remains hidden away from the public gaze, the nomadic 1872 Industrial Graces now serve as the sole guardians of the King’s Inns lawn.

THE SAD STORY OF HENRIETTA